Medical billing requests for proposals (RFPs) can fail if the requirements are too vague to evaluate or the payments infrastructure layer (i.e., what happens when a patient owes money) is left out. The result is proposals you can’t compare and contracts that don’t hold vendors accountable.

Below, we’ll discuss what needs to be included in a medical billing RFP, how to write one that elicits useful vendor responses, and how to evaluate those responses.

Highlights

• A medical billing RFP needs to separate service requirements from technology requirements. Conflating them makes proposals harder to compare and obscures which party is accountable for what.

• Compliance and security criteria deserve serious weight in your scoring rubric. A vendor with a weak Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) posture or an outdated Payment Card Industry (PCI) assessment is a liability.

• Patient payments infrastructure is a distinct RFP consideration from billing services. As patients’ financial responsibility grows, the capability to handle installment plans, multichannel payments, and automated reconciliation has direct revenue implications.

What is a medical billing RFP?

A medical billing RFP is a formal document healthcare organizations use to evaluate billing service providers and billing technology vendors. As the party in need of services, it defines your requirements and asks vendors to explain how they would meet them, what outcomes they commit to, what it will cost, and how risk is allocated under the contract. A strong RFP covers all parts of the revenue cycle you expect a vendor to touch: claims submission, denial management, patient billing, payment processing, reporting, and system integration. And it doesn’t assume that all vendors will deliver those functions in the same way.

What should you include in a medical billing RFP?

The goal of an RFP is to give vendors enough context to respond and give you enough structure to fairly evaluate proposals. To achieve this, you need to include the following elements.

Organizational background and current state

First, describe your organization in concrete terms: specialty mix, patient volume, monthly claims volume, payer mix (e.g., commercial, Medicare, Medicaid, self-pay), and your current billing model (i.e., in-house, outsourced, or hybrid).

If you have them, include baseline revenue cycle metrics such as accounts receivable (AR) days over 90, clean claim rate, denial rate, and net collection rate. These metrics help vendors size the engagement properly and avoid unrealistic promises in the proposal stage.

Scope of work

Explain what’s in scope and what isn’t. Claims submission, eligibility verification, denial management, patient billing, payment posting, and reconciliation are distinct functions that are staffed and priced differently.

If you want the vendor to actively collect from patients rather than generate statements, include that function separately. Patient-facing collections change staffing models, technology requirements, and pricing.

Technical and integration requirements

Name your electronic health record (EHR) or electronic medical record (EMR) system, including the version. And describe the exact data flows you expect: demographic imports, charge feeds, claim status updates, and payment posting back into the clinical system.

Avoid vague requests for “automation.” Instead, describe the workflows you want to automate, such as eligibility checks at scheduling, claim scrubbing rules before submission, and denial routing by reason code.

Security and compliance

A set of controls will determine your exposure if something goes wrong. At a minimum, vendors must address:

• HIPAA safeguards and business associate agreement (BAA) terms

• Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard (PCI DSS) compliance level and most recent assessment date

• System and Organization Controls (SOC) 2 Type 2 certification

• Encryption standards for data at rest and in transit

• Audit trails for claims and payment activity

Pricing structure

Ask for pricing in enough detail to calculate the total cost of ownership rather than a monthly fee. That total includes per-claim fees, collection percentage models, implementation costs, support tiers, and transaction-level payment processing fees.

Evaluation criteria and timelines

Tell vendors how you’ll score their proposals and when you expect to make a decision. It filters out vendors that can’t meet your timeline and signals that you’re running a disciplined process.

How do you write a medical billing RFP?

Before you draft requirements, write down the two or three revenue cycle problems this RFP seeks to address. Every section needs to trace back to one of those issues. Beyond this, use the following best practices to write your medical billing RFP.

Separate requirements for service and technology

Billing service providers are accountable for outcomes, including clean claim rates, AR days, and denial resolution timelines. Technology vendors provide infrastructure and tooling, but the outcome remains your responsibility.

Some vendors offer both billing and technology services, but your RFP needs to evaluate these capabilities separately.

Specify integrations

Integration failures are a common reason for billing project overruns. Outline your EHR vendor, version, and required integration points. Ask vendors for client references that run the same EHR stack.

Define acceptable performance targets before you issue the RFP

If you don’t define an acceptable service level agreement (SLA), vendors can’t commit to it in their proposals or contracts. Set targets based on industry benchmarks: for example, an adjusted collection rate above 95% and AR between 30–40 days are common key performance indicator (KPI) targets for medical practices. Ask vendors to commit to these in writing.

Set a realistic timeline

A well-run medical billing RFP typically takes 8–12 weeks from issuance to vendor selection: a two- to three-week response window, internal scoring, finalist presentations, and reference checks. Compressing this process usually shifts risk downstream into the contract and implementation.

How does payments infrastructure support medical billing RFP goals?

Billing services and payments infrastructure are distinct, although RFPs often conflate them. Payment capabilities must be scrutinized on their own. Here’s how the two systems interact:

• Installment and payment plan support: A patient with a $2,000 bill needs options. Ask whether payment plans are automated or manually managed by staff. At scale, the distinction directly affects cost and patient experience.

• Multiple payment channels: Online, in-person, and phone payments all need to post to the same system without manual reconciliation. Each disconnected channel can introduce delays, errors, and write-offs.

• Automated reconciliation and reporting: Payment data needs to flow back into your billing system at the transaction level. Ask vendors how payment posting works. Then, ask what reporting granularity you get, such as by location, provider, payer type, or payment method. Aggregates tend to hide the problems you need to see.

Stripe Payments simplifies the payment process for medical practices by working in tandem with Stripe Billing to improve data visibility and reporting, as well as by tracking all payment types in one place and supporting installment payments.

What are some common mistakes in a medical billing RFP?

Many RFP mistakes aren’t obvious until you’re deep into implementation, by which point you’ve already signed a contract. Here are the mistakes worth catching early:

• Vague requirements: “Strong reporting” or “robust integrations” can’t be evaluated. Specify what you need, such as denial trends by reason code, payer performance by Current Procedural Terminology (CPT) code, and AR aging reports by provider. The more specific your requirements are, the more useful the responses will be.

• Undervaluing compliance: It’s easy to prioritize workflows and pricing and treat compliance as a checkbox. A weak HIPAA posture or an outdated PCI assessment is a liability. Score it accordingly.

• Ignoring transaction-level pricing: When vendors bill for services and process payments, fees are often bundled in opaque ways. Ask for explicit per-transaction costs. Percentage-based models can look reasonable until you calculate them at scale.

• Poor reference match: A vendor can perform well for large health systems and struggle with independent practices, and vice versa. Ask for references that match your specialty mix, volume, and EHR stack.

• Deferring SLAs to the contract stage: If your performance expectations aren’t in the RFP, vendors have no incentive to address them in proposals. You then lose your strongest position in negotiations.

How do you evaluate responses to a medical billing RFP?

Compelling proposals are hard to objectively score. If your team scores independently, you need a shared framework.

Here’s how to build structure into that process:

• Set scoring weights in advance: Agree internally on weights for compliance and security, integration capability, pricing transparency, service model, and references. Document them before responses come in.

• Use scores to short-list, not decide: Scoring identifies finalists. A judgment makes the final call. A slightly lower-scoring vendor with better specialty references or clearer pricing might be the stronger long-term partner.

• Press vendors on operations: Go beyond the demo. In finalist presentations, ask vendors to walk through real scenarios, such as a denial from your top payer, a HIPAA breach in the first 90 days, or the average integration timeline for clients of your size. Their answers can tell you more than a polished slide deck might.

• Run legal review in parallel: Have legal review contracts alongside business evaluation. SLAs, BAA terms, data ownership, and termination rights are easier to negotiate before you announce a preferred vendor.

• Check references with pointed questions: Ask what broke during implementation, how long it took to fix, and whether projected claim volumes matched reality.

How Stripe Billing can help

Stripe Billing lets you bill and manage customers however you want—from simple recurring billing to usage-based billing and sales-negotiated contracts. Start accepting recurring payments globally in minutes—no code required—or build a custom integration using the application programming interface (API).

Stripe Billing can help you:

• Offer flexible pricing: Respond to user demand faster with flexible pricing models, including usage-based, tiered, flat-fee plus overage, and more. Support for coupons, free trials, prorations, and add-ons is built in.

• Expand globally: Increase conversion by offering customers’ preferred payment methods. Stripe supports 100+ local payment methods and 130+ currencies.

• Increase revenue and reduce churn: Improve revenue capture and reduce involuntary churn with Smart Retries and recovery workflow automations. Stripe recovery tools helped users recover over $6.5 billion in revenue in 2024.

• Boost efficiency: Use Stripe’s modular tax, revenue reporting, and data tools to consolidate multiple revenue systems into one. Easily integrate with third-party software.

Learn more about Stripe Billing, or get started today.