The average revenue generated from a request for proposal (RFP) in the healthcare industry exceeds $1 billion, but winning one is no small feat. Healthcare billing RFPs, the documents healthcare organizations issue to find a billing vendor, carry special requirements. Important areas such as protected health information (PHI) exposure, the challenges of the government payer landscape, denial management, and patient payment sensitivity all need to be covered in the document itself. They can’t surface for the first time when you’re comparing proposals or negotiating a contract.

Below, we’ll go over some healthcare RFP examples, how to run the RFP process, and how to evaluate what you receive from vendors.

Highlights:

• A healthcare billing RFP should explicitly address PHI handling, electronic health records (EHR) integration specifics, and denial management processes.

• The distinction between a billing services RFP and a billing technology RFP shapes everything from scope-of-work language to pricing structure.

• Modern payments infrastructure can strengthen vendor proposals by consolidating patient payment acceptance, recurring billing, and reconciliation into a single integration.

What is a healthcare billing RFP?

A healthcare billing RFP is a formal document a healthcare organization issues when it’s seeking a vendor to handle some or all of its billing operations, billing technology, or both. It defines the scope, compliance requirements, technical specifications, and the criteria by which proposals are scored.

What are examples of sections a healthcare billing RFP should include?

The structure of a well-built healthcare billing RFP generally follows a predictable sequence, even if the content varies by organization size, specialty, and payer mix. Each section serves a specific function.

Project overview

Explain why you’re seeking a vendor and be specific. Name the problems, whether that’s a denial rate above industry benchmarks, a patient collections workflow still running on paper statements, or an EHR migration that broke reconciliation between clinical and billing systems.

Scope of services

List what you need the vendor to handle: claims lifecycle management, coding support, patient invoicing and collections, insurance reconciliation, or reporting. Every item you include becomes something vendors must address, which increases response length and evaluation time.

Technology integration requirements

Specify which EHR or practice management system (PMS) the vendor must integrate with, whether you require application programming interface (API)-first architecture or will accept file-based data exchange, and whether the system can match payments to claims without manual intervention. If you run a subscription- or membership-based care model, indicate that as well.

Compliance and reporting requirements

Require vendors to address safeguards for PHI, Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard (PCI DSS) compliance for payment processing, audit logging for all claim activity, and financial reporting that gives your finance team clear visibility into collections performance and outstanding accounts receivable (AR).

Pricing requirements

Ask for itemized pricing—bundled rates obscure what you’re paying per service component. Request per-claim transaction costs, integration and onboarding fees, training costs, and any performance-based structures where vendor fees are tied to collection outcomes.

Evaluation criteria and performance metrics

Define the benchmarks you’ll use to score both RFP responses and vendor performance after implementation, such as clean claim rate targets, days in AR, first pass resolution rate (FPRR), and service level agreement (SLA) commitments for denial follow-up. Including these in the RFP signals to vendors that you’ll hold them accountable and filters out anyone unwilling to commit to specific numbers.

What makes healthcare billing RFPs unique compared to other industries?

A few things set healthcare billing RFPs apart from RFPs for logistics software or financial services. The combination of PHI exposure, government payer challenges, denials management, and patient payment sensitivity creates a unique set of needs. Here’s how.

PHI exposure at every layer

Many billing transactions involve protected health information, which means vendor contracts require agreements such as business associate agreements (BAAs) in the US. The RFP needs to ask vendors to describe exactly how PHI is handled, stored, transmitted, and what happens to it at contract termination.

Government payer complexity

Government billing, such as Medicare and Medicaid in the US, operates under rules that commercial payer billing doesn’t. Vendors working in this space need to understand government billing guidelines, local coverage determinations (LCDs), and the specific claim formats required by government programs. An RFP that doesn’t specify that government program experience is necessary is likely to receive responses from vendors that handle commercial claims well but struggle with government payers.

Denials management

When managing healthcare billing, denials are a routine part of operations. How a vendor handles them determines a substantial portion of your revenue recovery. Ask vendors to describe their denial management process in detail, including average appeal success rates and timelines.

Patient payment sensitivity

Patients might be confused about what they owe and why, and an aggressive collections experience can damage the care relationship. Your RFP should ask vendors how they handle communications with patients, what payment assistance options they support, and how they manage accounts before sending them to external collections.

How does a healthcare billing RFP work in practice?

The healthcare RFP process can take weeks, though complicated health systems with multiple service lines might run longer. Here are the steps you need to know.

Internal agreement

Define the scope and get stakeholder sign-off from finance, clinical operations, information technology (IT), and compliance before the RFP goes out. Vendors might ask questions your team hasn’t answered yet, so it’s better to address them internally first.

Market scan

Identify vendors to receive the RFP through a combination of known vendors, referrals, and responses to a preliminary request for information (RFI). Don’t skip the RFI step if you’re entering a category where you don’t have strong knowledge of existing vendors.

Issuance and question and answer period

Distribute the RFP with a deadline for vendor questions, then publish answers to all respondents simultaneously. This keeps the process fair and prevents well-connected vendors from getting information others don’t.

Proposal review

Score responses against your evaluation criteria with a cross-functional review team. Finance, IT, and compliance will often catch issues that a review done by only procurement misses.

Shortlisting and demonstrations

Bring some finalists in for live demonstrations or system walkthroughs, with scenarios drawn from your actual billing environment rather than vendor-prepared scripts.

Reference checks

Contact current clients in your specialty or size range; don’t rely only on the references the vendor volunteered. Ask specifically about denial management performance and EHR integration reliability.

Contract negotiation

Use the pricing and SLA commitments from the RFP response as the baseline. If a vendor tries to renege on specifics at contracting, that’s a signal worth taking seriously.

How does modern payments infrastructure strengthen a healthcare billing proposal?

When vendors describe their payment capabilities in an RFP response, the gap between legacy billing systems and modern payments infrastructure can become visible fast. Keep the following in mind.

Unified payment acceptance

Unified infrastructure supports card and digital wallet acceptance, automated invoicing, and payment plan management. That matters in an RFP context because it means the vendor isn’t piecing together separate systems for in-person payments, online patient portals, and recurring billing; reconciliation runs through one integration consistently across all of them.

Subscription and membership billing

Organizations that have moved toward subscription-based or membership care models need to handle recurring charges and automatic proration for plan changes. Many legacy billing platforms weren’t built for that, resulting in manual reconciliation work, reporting gaps, and error-prone workarounds.

PCI DSS compliance

PCI DSS Level 1 compliance covers the payment processing layer of what a healthcare billing RFP’s compliance section typically requires. Building on compliant payments infrastructure simplifies PCI maintenance for healthcare organizations.

EHR interoperability

A vendor that operates as a payment provider rather than only a billing services company can integrate with existing EHR and PMSs instead of displacing them. That’s exactly what vendors need to demonstrate when your RFP asks about EHR interoperability.

Stripe Billing unifies billing and payments on a single platform that’s PCI DSS Level 1 certified and built for global use.

What risks and constraints should a healthcare billing RFP account for?

A well-structured RFP reduces vendor risk, but it doesn’t eliminate it. Many of the constraints can be addressed in how you write the RFP.

Scope creep in contracting

Vendors might respond to broad RFP language with broad proposals, then narrow the scope substantially at the contract stage. Write your scope-of-work section specifically enough that the contract has to reflect what the proposal described.

Integration overconfidence

“We integrate with [EHR name]” can mean anything from a certified bidirectional integration to a comma-separated values (CSV) export. Ask vendors to describe the integration in detail, including which data flows in which direction, at what frequency, and what breaks when the EHR updates. Integrations can also vary in terms of engineering effort required for implementation. Ask what level of development is required from your organization to enable the integration.

Performance metrics that disappear after signing

The clean claim rates and AR benchmarks vendors promise in their RFP responses need to appear in the contract with defined consequences for missing them. They’re not commitments if they’re absent from the SLA.

PHI at contract termination

Before you sign, be sure the vendor explains what happens to patient data when you switch vendors. Return timelines, destruction certifications, and data format requirements all need to be enumerated in the RFP so that vendors address them in their proposals rather than negotiating them under pressure later.

Implementation timeline risk

Vendors might underestimate go-live timelines, particularly when EHR integration is involved. Ask vendors to provide implementation timelines from comparable engagements and build contract milestones around those numbers.

How do you evaluate responses to a healthcare billing RFP?

In general, you’ll want to score proposals against the criteria you defined in the RFP.

Here are some best practices:

• Blind scoring for the first pass: Have reviewers score proposals against criteria before vendor presentations, so first impressions don’t skew the evaluation. Remember to use a cross-functional team for review.

• Penalize vague responses: Proposals that describe processes in general terms should score lower than those that name the process, the tools, and the metrics. Vagueness in a proposal tends to be a reliable predictor of vagueness in a contract.

• Weigh criteria by business impact: If your biggest problem is denial rates, that criterion needs to carry more weight than reporting dashboard design. Build your scoring rubric before proposals arrive, so vendor responses don’t shape how you’re evaluating them.

• Watch for drift from proposal to contract: The evaluation process is also a place where you can catch vendors that failed to address the problems you described. A proposal that addresses every RFP item but never engages with the specific challenges you named in the project overview is likely telling you something about how that vendor communicates once they’re under contract.

How Stripe Billing can help

Stripe Billing lets you bill and manage customers however you want—from simple recurring billing to usage-based billing and sales-negotiated contracts. Start accepting recurring payments globally in minutes—no code required—or build a custom integration using the API.

Stripe Billing can help you:

• Offer flexible pricing: Respond to user demand faster with flexible pricing models, including usage-based, tiered, flat-fee plus overage, and more. Support for coupons, free trials, prorations, and add-ons is built in.

• Expand globally: Increase conversion by offering customers’ preferred payment methods. Stripe supports 100+ local payment methods and 130+ currencies.

• Increase revenue and reduce churn: Improve revenue capture and reduce involuntary churn with Smart Retries and recovery workflow automations. Stripe recovery tools helped users recover over $6.5 billion in revenue in 2024.

• Boost efficiency: Use Stripe’s modular tax, revenue reporting, and data tools to consolidate multiple revenue systems into one. Easily integrate with third-party software.

Learn more about Stripe Billing, or get started today.