Subscription marketplaces explained: How they work and how to build one


Stripe Billing lets you bill and manage customers however you want – from simple recurring billing to usage-based billing and sales-negotiated contracts.

Learn more 
  1. Introduction
  2. What is a subscription marketplace?
  3. Key components of a subscription marketplace
  4. What are the challenges of building a subscription marketplace?
  5. Key considerations of subscription marketplace payment processing
  6. How to create a subscription marketplace

The size of the global e-commerce subscription market is projected to top US$904 billion by the end of 2026. This remarkable growth not only signals a change in consumer behaviour, but also reveals an emerging opportunity for businesses to tap into a new recurring revenue stream.

For businesses, adopting a subscription business model means embracing a customer-centric approach that builds lasting relationships, enhances brand loyalty and offers predictable revenue. It's not just about transactions any more – it's about creating experiences that keep customers engaged in the long term. While the opportunities are vast, building a subscription marketplace also presents its own unique challenges, such as selecting the right technology platform, creating a seamless user experience, managing vendors and ensuring efficient payment processing.

A well-structured subscription marketplace can foster customer loyalty, facilitate access to a wider customer base for vendors and generate steady revenue for platform owners. We'll cover what you need to know about creating a subscription marketplace, offering insights into how businesses can harness this transformative trend to their advantage.

What's in this article?

  • What is a subscription marketplace?
  • Key components of a subscription marketplace
  • What are the challenges of building a subscription marketplace?
  • Key considerations of subscription marketplace payment processing
  • How to create a subscription marketplace

What is a subscription marketplace?

A subscription marketplace is a digital platform that hosts multiple subscription-based businesses, allowing users to discover, compare and purchase subscription services in various categories. These categories can range from digital services, such as streaming platforms, software-as-a-service (SaaS) solutions and online courses, to physical goods, such as meal kit deliveries, beauty boxes and book clubs. Typically, marketplace owners monetise the platform by taking a commission on each transaction or charging businesses a fee for listing their subscriptions.

From a user's perspective, a subscription marketplace can offer convenience in managing multiple subscriptions, as well as a way to discover new services. For subscription businesses, it's a chance to reach a larger audience – one that might be otherwise unreachable without the marketplace.

Key components of a subscription marketplace

A subscription marketplace operates at the intersection of e-commerce and the growing subscription economy, creating a central hub for consumers to manage their subscriptions and discover new offerings. The system is designed to benefit consumers, service providers and the platform owner, and each plays a crucial role. Here are the essential components of a subscription marketplace:

  • Vendor onboarding
    Vendor onboarding involves enlisting subscription-based businesses to offer their services or products on the marketplace. A streamlined onboarding process – one that includes setting up pricing, product descriptions and images – can help attract a diverse range of vendors.

  • Subscription management
    A core component of the marketplace is an effective subscription management system. It should allow customers to sign up for, modify or cancel subscriptions seamlessly. It should also handle automatic renewals, payment processing and reminders.

  • Payment processing
    The marketplace needs a secure and efficient payment processing system, which should support different payment methods and handle recurring payments, refunds and cancellations.

  • Search and discovery
    The platform should have a user-friendly interface that enables customers to search for and discover subscription services easily. Features such as categorisation, filters and personalised recommendations can enhance the user experience.

  • Customer service
    A robust customer service system is essential for handling queries, complaints and issues related to subscriptions. This means providing support for both the end-users and the subscription businesses.

  • Analytics and reporting
    For the subscription businesses, the marketplace should provide analytics and reports on sales, customer behaviour and subscription trends. These insights can help businesses refine their offerings and strategies.

  • Promotion and marketing
    The marketplace should also offer promotion and marketing tools to help businesses reach a larger audience. This could include featured listings, promotional campaigns and integrations with social media platforms.

What are the challenges of building a subscription marketplace?

Creating a subscription marketplace means taking on multiple challenges, each of which can be conquered with a mix of strategic foresight, a comprehensive understanding of potential users and expert implementation of technology. These challenges include:

  • Vendor onboarding
    Acquiring a diverse range of high-quality vendors can be a difficult and time-consuming process. A burgeoning subscription marketplace must convince vendors – who might have concerns about competition, pricing control and brand image – of the benefits of listing their products or services on the marketplace.

  • User acquisition and retention
    Building a user base for a subscription marketplace is a considerable challenge. The platform must attract consumers who are interested in subscription services and persuade them to manage their subscriptions through the marketplace. It's equally crucial to retain these users and ensure that they don't unsubscribe or switch to direct subscriptions with vendors.

  • Technical complexity
    Implementing the technology to handle subscription management, payment processing, search and discovery, customer service and analytics can be complex. Each function requires robust and scalable solutions that can handle large volumes of transactions and data.

  • Legal and regulatory compliance
    The marketplace needs to comply with a multitude of legal and regulatory requirements, including those related to privacy, data security, consumer rights and taxation. These requirements can vary across different jurisdictions, adding further complexity.

  • Trust and security
    Building trust with both consumers and vendors is essential. This includes ensuring that transactions are secure, protecting user data, providing reliable customer service and resolving disputes fairly.

  • Monetisation
    Developing a sustainable business model for the marketplace is another challenge. Typically, this involves charging commissions or levying listing fees on vendors, but setting the right price levels can be tricky. If the fees are too high, they might deter vendors. If they are too low, they might not cover the costs of running the marketplace.

Key considerations of subscription marketplace payment processing

Subscription marketplace payment processing is a critical element in the successful operation and growth of the platform. It's not just about enabling transactions – it's about making strategic decisions, understanding the nuances of the business model and ensuring global operational efficiency. Here are some of the most critical aspects to consider:

  • Strategic partnership with a payment provider
    Instead of viewing payment providers simply as a tool for transactions, think of them as a strategic ally that can catalyse growth. This requires engaging a provider who is in sync with your long-term business objectives, supports scaling into new markets and stays abreast of the ever-evolving landscape of payment trends and technologies. With the right partner, businesses can tap into emerging opportunities and future-proof their payment processes.

  • Compliance as a competitive advantage
    While ensuring regulatory compliance, such as adherence to PCI-DSS, is a must, it can also be a value proposition. Instead of simple compliance, businesses should aim for excellence in data security, which will help to foster an environment of trust. Going above and beyond the basic requirements can help your subscription marketplace build a strong security infrastructure that reassures users and sets your platform apart.

  • Proactive fraud prevention
    In the face of sophisticated cyber threats, taking a reactive stance against fraud is no longer sufficient. A proactive approach, using advanced technologies such as machine learning and AI-based fraud detection systems, can pre-empt and mitigate potential fraudulent activities. This not only minimises financial loss but also enhances user trust and platform credibility.

  • Personalisation and optimisation of payment methods
    Expanding payment options is more than just adding checkboxes. By understanding the demographic and psychographic characteristics of your users, you can tailor the payment experience to their preferences and habits. In turn, this will enhance the overall user experience and potentially boost conversion rates.

  • Hyper-localisation for global marketplaces
    Global marketplaces need to consider payment localisation in a nuanced manner. Beyond supporting local payment methods, marketplaces need to understand and comply with local regulations, account for regional taxation rules and consider cultural preferences in payment and billing practices. This localised approach can significantly increase user adoption and satisfaction in different markets.

  • Advanced recurring billing management
    The recurring billing process in subscription services involves managing various scenarios, from voluntary and involuntary churn to dunning management and proration of charges for plan changes. An advanced, flexible billing system that handles these scenarios in an elegant way can enhance the user experience and contribute to user retention.

  • Payment data as business intelligence
    Payment data can be a gold mine of insights for your business. By integrating the payment gateway with business intelligence tools, you can derive insights on customer behaviour, payment trends and churn patterns. This can inform strategic decisions and help you to adapt and optimise your offerings and processes.

By taking a more intentional, nuanced approach, businesses can transform payment processing from a back-end operation into a source of competitive advantage. This comprehensive perspective can enhance the user experience, provide valuable insights and contribute to the sustainable growth of the subscription marketplace.

How to create a subscription marketplace

Creating a subscription marketplace requires building a solid foundation, delivering a seamless user experience and setting the stage for sustainable growth. This means understanding your target audience, building a reliable and powerful technical platform, nurturing relationships with vendors and cultivating highly efficient operations. Here's a deeper look at the process:

  • Defining your value proposition
    Start by defining what unique value your marketplace will bring to both vendors and customers. This involves understanding your target audience's needs and pain points, and clarifying how your marketplace can address them better than existing solutions. Will you specialise in a certain niche or offer a wide range of subscription services? What key features or services will set your marketplace apart?

  • Building the technology platform
    Building the marketplace involves creating a user-friendly interface for customers to browse, subscribe to and manage their subscriptions. It also involves creating a vendor portal for managing listings, payments and customer interactions. Consider key features such as search and discovery, subscription management, payment processing and customer service. Choose technology solutions that are scalable, secure and flexible enough to evolve with your business.

  • Vendor acquisition and relationship management
    Finding high-quality vendors is a critical step. You'll need a strategy to attract them to your platform, which might involve marketing efforts, partnerships or direct sales. Once you've onboarded vendors, it's essential to build and maintain good relationships with them. This could involve providing analytics and insights, offering promotional tools and creating a supportive community.

  • Customer acquisition and retention
    Acquiring customers who are interested in subscription services is another critical task. This might involve search engine optimisation (SEO), paid advertising, content marketing and social media marketing. Retention strategies could include excellent customer service, personalised recommendations and loyalty programmes.

  • Legal and regulatory compliance
    Ensure that your marketplace complies with all relevant laws and regulations, including data protection and privacy laws, consumer rights legislation and payment industry standards. This might involve working with legal professionals to review your terms of service, privacy policy and operational practices.

  • Revenue model and monetisation
    Decide how you will generate revenue. This could involve charging vendors a commission on sales, a listing fee or a combination of both. Consider which pricing model will be competitive yet sustainable.

  • Testing and iterating
    Before launching, test your marketplace with a selected group of vendors and customers to gather feedback and make necessary adjustments. After launching, continue to gather feedback, monitor performance and make improvements.

  • Scaling your marketplace
    Once your marketplace is up and running, consider strategies for growth. This might involve expanding into new markets, adding new categories of subscriptions, forming partnerships or increasing marketing efforts.

Creating a subscription marketplace is a complex but rewarding process. With a well-informed approach and a focus on providing value, you can build a successful platform that meets – and exceeds – the needs of both vendors and customers. As with any business venture, this process involves continuous learning, adapting and improving. Learn more about how Stripe powers payments for marketplaces here.

Ready to get started?

Create an account and start accepting payments – no contracts or banking details required. Or, contact us to design a custom package for your business.